Romance That Doesn’t Cringe (…Or Does, On Purpose!)

Let’s be honest. Romance in YA is tricky business. Done well? Your readers will be staying up past midnight, whispering “just one more chapter” like it’s a prayer. Done badly? You’ll get eye-rolls so intense they could power a small city.

And the thing is, teens know when romance feels fake. We’ve grown up in a world of streaming dramas, TikTok ship edits, and books where every trope has been done ten times over. So if you want your romance to hit? It needs to feel real — or knowingly ridiculous.

Yes, there are two equally valid roads here:

1. Swoony, believable romance that melts hearts.
2. Self-aware cringe that’s so bad, it’s brilliant.

Let’s talk about how to nail both.

Chemistry Is the Currency

Tropes are the window dressing. Chemistry is the foundation. Without it, you’ve just got a couple of cardboard cut-outs awkwardly standing next to each other.

How to build chemistry that doesn’t feel forced:

• Shared moments before the big “I like you” reveal. Let them have inside jokes, running competitions, and shared struggles.
• Notice the little things. Not “her eyes sparkled like stars” (please, no). More like “he always saves the green jellybeans for her.”
• Make them comfortable and uncomfortable. The best romance has both safety and tension — the feeling of being at home, but also being just a little off-balance.

If you’re going for cringe,push the chemistry into hyperbole. Their eyes meet and “the entire room faded into a hazy blur of destiny.” Yep, go there. Make it a choice.

Dialogue That Doesn’t Make Readers Gag

Bad romantic dialogue is the fastest way to lose your reader’s trust.

To keep it natural:

• Stay true to character voice. A sarcastic character will confess love differently than a soft-spoken one.
• Mix in humour. Playful banter can carry a romance without getting syrupy.
• Use interruptions. Conversations rarely happen in perfect, uninterrupted blocks — let someone trip over a word, get distracted, or blurt something awkward.

If you’re going for cringe:Use every cliché in the book — “I’ve loved you since the moment we locked eyes across the crowded cafeteria” — but then have another character point out how over-the-top it is. That’s the wink to the audience that makes it work.

Lean Into the Awkward

In real life, teen romance is not a Pinterest mood board. It’s fumbling for words, texting something too fast, bumping noses when you go in for a kiss.

Write the mess:

• First date? Someone drops their drink.
• First confession? The fire alarm goes off halfway through.
• First kiss? Someone’s dog won’t stop barking in the background.

When you let those imperfect beats live on the page, the sweet moments feel earned.

If you’re going for cringe:Turn the awkwardness up to 100. Have your character declare love mid-sneeze. Accidentally send the wrong emoji. Kiss in a photo booth and get stuck halfway through.

Tropes Are Tools — Not the Whole House

We all have our comfort tropes. Enemies-to-lovers, fake dating, best friend’s sibling… they’re popular because they work. But if you lean only on the trope without adding depth, the romance will feel hollow.

To keep it fresh:

• Subvert expectations. In a fake dating story, maybe one person catches real feelings… but for someone else entirely.
• Layer the trope with personal stakes. Why does this relationship matter to them beyond romance?

If you’re going for cringe:Stack tropes on tropes. Enemies-to-lovers… who are also secretly royalty… who get stuck in one bed… during a snowstorm. Go all in.

Romance Beyond the Kiss

The big kiss (or “I love you”) isn’t the finish line. In fact, the most romantic moments often happen before that point. Think sharing an umbrella in the rain, writing notes in the margins of each other’s books or remembering their coffee order without asking.

These tiny acts of care tell the reader this is love without screaming it in neon lights.

If you’re going for cringe:Still do the tiny acts… but make them absurdly extra. They don’t just remember the coffee order — they have it written into a song and performed at assembly.

Let the Reader Be in On It

Whether you’re aiming for genuine or over-the-top, the reader should feel like they’re in the front row, watching it unfold.

Ways to invite them in:

• Use sensory details — the sound of a heartbeat in a quiet room, the scent of laundry powder on someone’s hoodie.
• Give us the internal commentary — the way a character’s brain melts into nonsense when the love interest looks at them.
• In cringe-mode, break the fourth wall. Have your character know it’s dramatic and roll with it anyway.

Jessi’s Romance Tropes Cheat Sheet

Here is a Romance Tropes cheat sheet because sometimes you want the swoon… and sometimes you want the cheese.  Simply pick your trope, decide: melt hearts or make them laugh and then write the same scene both ways to see how tone transforms it.

---

Like what you’ve read? Why not buy us a coffee to keep the ideas brewing? ☕ Your support means we can keep sharing free content with the writing community. You can show your appreciation at BuyMeACoffee. Remember, Scribbly, including The Scribbler, is run entirely by volunteers, so every contribution counts. Thanks for your support!