Cleverness should be the seasoning, not the meal. Use it with intention, and it will shine. But never forget that the reader came for the story, not the performance. Strip it back until the meaning stands clear, and then — only then — decide where to let the cleverness bloom
There’s a temptation, especially for those of us who love language, to lace every sentence with sparkle. We reach for the unusual turn of phrase, the elegant clause, the perfectly placed metaphor — not because it’s the clearest choice, but because it’s clever.
And sometimes, that’s exactly what’s needed. Cleverness can delight, surprise, and make a reader pause in admiration. But cleverness can also become a fog. If your reader must stop mid-sentence to decode what you meant, you’ve lost them.
Clarity: The Backbone of Good Writing
Clarity isn’t the enemy of art; it’s the foundation. Without it, even the most beautifully crafted line will fall flat. Clear writing allows your reader to follow you without stumbling, to engage with your meaning without having to dig through unnecessary complexity.
Think of clarity as the path you’re leading your reader down. Cleverness is the flowering tree along that path — beautiful and worth noticing — but useless if it’s blocking the way forward.
The Australian Government Style Manual, a trusted reference for plain language in public documents, is blunt about this: “Write so your audience understands what you mean the first time they read it.” While the manual is aimed at government writers, the principle applies everywhere — even in fiction. Whether you’re writing a Moreton Bay memoir, a Brisbane business blog, or a national op-ed, readers value understanding more than verbal acrobatics.
When Cleverness Works
Cleverness earns its keep when it adds meaning, not just decoration. A striking turn of phrase can sharpen an image, reveal a character’s personality, or capture a truth in a way that lodges in the reader’s memory.
Australian novelist Tim Winton is often cited for his lyrical style. His sentences are musical, but they never leave the reader stranded. He can describe a Fremantle afternoon with a metaphor so fresh you feel the sun yourself — yet the meaning is never buried under the beauty. That’s cleverness doing its job: enriching, not obscuring.
In contrast, I’ve read manuscripts where the cleverness works like a locked gate — you admire it from the outside, but it keeps you from getting where you need to go.
The Strip-Back Test
When I’m editing my own work or mentoring another writer, I use what I call the “strip-back test.” Take a sentence and reduce it to its simplest form — the bones. Ask yourself: Does the meaning still stand? If the only thing holding it together was the flourish, the flourish goes.
Here’s a simple example:
Clever-but-cloudy: “The dawn broke like a hesitant guest, loitering in the doorway of the day.”
Stripped-back clarity: “The dawn came slowly.”
The first version could work in the right moment, for the right mood. But if the scene is about urgency, that long, poetic image will trip the pace. Sometimes a straight line is faster and truer.
One of the best ways to test clarity is to read your work aloud to someone who isn’t a writer. Watch their face. Do they lean in? Or do they frown, glaze over, or politely nod while their mind wanders? The Queensland Writers Centre often tells workshop participants: “Your reader is the final authority on clarity.” If they don’t understand, the sentence hasn’t done its job — no matter how much you love it.
Practical Ways to Strip Back Without Losing Beauty
Stripping back isn’t about making your writing bland. It’s about removing anything that stops the reader from seeing the heart of your meaning.
- Swap the obscure for the precise. A short, concrete word is often more powerful than a long, vague one.
- Cut repetition disguised as emphasis. Trust the reader to remember.
- Break long sentences into two shorter ones when they start to sprawl.
- Keep metaphors in check — one strong image will always beat three tangled ones competing for attention.
I once worked with a poet from the Sunshine Coast whose first drafts were dense with metaphor. Gorgeous work, but exhausting to read. We stripped back to a single metaphor per stanza, and the result was more powerful than the original. The meaning shone through without the reader having to fight for it.
Clarity Across Different Forms
In fiction, clarity helps your reader stay immersed in the world you’ve built. You can still play with voice, rhythm, and style — but the reader shouldn’t be yanked out of the story trying to decipher a line.
In a memoir, clarity builds trust. Your reader is investing in your truth; if they can’t follow your meaning, the connection is lost.
In business writing, clarity is non-negotiable. Clients and customers will not read your paragraph three times to work out what you’re offering.
In poetry, you might think cleverness is everything — but the best poems use it sparingly, like spice. A dash changes the flavour. A tablespoon ruins the meal.
Finding the Balance
The balance between clarity and cleverness is rarely perfect in a first draft. That’s what editing is for. My advice: write freely in draft mode — let the cleverness spill out — and then, in revision, put on your reader’s hat. Ask whether every word is helping them understand, or helping you show off.
Cleverness should be the seasoning, not the meal. Use it with intention, and it will shine. But never forget that the reader came for the story, not the performance. Strip it back until the meaning stands clear, and then — only then — decide where to let the cleverness bloom.
Like what you’ve read? Why not buy us a coffee to keep the ideas brewing? ☕ Your support means we can keep sharing free content with the writing community. You can show your appreciation at BuyMeACoffee. Remember, Scribbly, including The Scribbler, is run entirely by volunteers, so every contribution counts. Thanks for your support!